Polonomic Weekly;
Gold Doesn’t Always Glitter

From the Polonomic Weekly newsletter.
Subscribe here.

Liam Scotchmer
No AI was used. References below.

Gold is important for both its physical properties and its psychological appeal.
Gold is a symbol of wealth, power, and prestige across many cultures and has been so throughout history. This is partly due to its scarcity (it’s a rare earth metal after all), but it is still abundant enough to serve “as a practical medium of exchange.” On being a medium of exchange, gold is very durable; hard to lose and destroy, compared to metals like iron, copper, and lead which are prone to corrode over time.

It is practical and has symbolic value, striking a middle ground between digital consensus (bitcoin) and government backing (paper money). It is “a physical asset with tangible worth and a value driven by trust in its continued worth.”

Why Is Gold Important?

As crypto enthusiasts tout digital currencies and central banks explore digital alternatives, gold’s price has nevertheless soared past $6000AUD per ounce. Why? Well the demand is both for practical and psychological reasons.

Central banks hold one-fifth of the world’s supply in their vaults, implying that even in the digital age, physical gold provides security. It is a store of value, with its value remaining quite stable rather than declining.
That’s one reason for gold's demand, another is gold is a psychological anchor; when other assets fall, “the human instinct to seek gold’s perceived safety kicks in.” Third; it is a component in electronics, medicine, and aerospace which boost demand for the metal. Lastly, gold is a useful hedge against inflation.

Gold’s Ascent

Despite gold's ascent in recent years, it is down 15% since the American-Israeli war against Iran began on February 28.

What is going on? Firstly, compare inflation protected bonds (or real yields) to gold; both are protected against rising prices, but the bond offers interest payments, gold does not. When the coupon payments of those bonds rise, gold which pays nothing, becomes less appealing. And this is happening; the yield on 10 year American Treasuries has risen by 0.3 percentage points as a result of a riskier global environment.

Another reason is when gold rallies, as it has in the last few years, central banks (who typically hold large amounts of gold) can sell it to generate cash. On March 20th, Turkey sold $8billion worth of gold to prop up the lira. This pushes the price down.

One other explanation is that the past few weeks have shown that gold is not a complete universal hedge; it can’t protect against Gulf wars, or an energy shock, hence the fall. Instead gold protects against the debasement of money, per The Economist. Debasement is when the supply of money is increased, lowering the nominal value of each unit. This is done so governments can spend more without implementing taxes and impacting people’s finances. Debasement is a giant risk at the moment because of mounting public debts; but in the long term debasing leads to inflation, something gold supposedly protects against. However, when the meme traders outnumber the debasement traders and when institutional investors sell at a profit to cover losses on other assets, it doesn’t behave like a pure debasement hedge.

It seems there are many forces distorting the price of gold.

Gold Doesn’t Always Glitter

References

Magazine, B. (2023, October 27). What Is Monetary Debasement? Bitcoin Magazine. https://bitcoinmagazine.com/glossary/debasement

News, M. (n.d.). The Surprising Uses of Gold Throughout History. Mirage News. https://www.miragenews.com/the-surprising-uses-of-gold-throughout-history-1023833/

Tardi, C. (2021, February 23). Why Has Gold Always Been Valuable? Investopedia. https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/071114/why-gold-has-always-had-value.asp

The Economist. (2026, March 30). After Iran, gold is looking less glittery. The Economist. https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2026/03/30/after-iran-gold-is-looking-less-glittery